Development and validation of an echocardiography score for diagnosis of cardiac masses

Background Echocardiography is the cornerstone in the evaluation of cardiac masses and provides accurate characterization. Despite, its accuracy in diagnosis of cardiac masses (CM) remains challenging and, up to date, no validated diagnostic algorithm is validated. Purpose The aim of our study was to evaluate the diagnostic accuracy of echocardiography, to identify the echocardiographic predictors of malignancy and to develop and then validate a multiparametric echocardiographic score that could be used to estimate the likelihood of the histological nature of a CM. Materials and methods The final sample consisted of 273 consecutive patients who had a 2D-echocardiographic evaluation and a histologic diagnosis. Logistic regression was performed to evaluate the ability of echocardiographic findings to discriminate benign versus malignant masses, then a scoring system was developed and validated in a separate test cohort. Results Of the 322 patients initially included in the Bologna Cardiac Masses Registry, 13 with a poor acoustic window, 27 with no histological examination patients and 9 extra-cardiac masses were excluded. In the remaining 273 patients, classical 2-D echocardiogram identified 249 masses with a diagnostic accuracy of 88%. A weighted score [Diagnostic Echocardiographic Mass (DEM) Score] ranging from 0 to 9 was obtained from 6 variables: infiltration, polylobate mass, moderate-severe pericardial effusion. The AUC for the score was 0.965 (95% CI [0.938-0.993]). In a logistic regression analysis using the DEM score as a predictor, the likelihood of malignant CM increased more than 4 times for a 1-unit increase in the score (OR=4.468; 95% CI 2.733-7.304). A score < 3 denoted a high probability of a benign diagnosis, and a score ≥ 5 points corresponded to a higher risk of malignancy. Conclusion 2D-Echocardiography provides a high diagnostic accuracy in identifying cardiac masses and our multiparametric echocardiographic score could be useful to predict the histological nature of cardiac masses.